• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Country Crust Bakery: A Delightful Destination for Homemade Treats and Comfort Food

Country Crust Bakery, nestled in the heart of Bainbridge, Ohio, embodies the warmth of Amish cooking in a charming outdoor setting. Known for its mouthwatering sandwiches featuring fresh pretzel buns, and delectable homemade pies—such as pecan, peach, and apple—this bakery offers a delightful array of baked goods, including artisanal breads and sweet treats. The heartfelt service adds to the inviting atmosphere, making each visit not just a meal, but a memorable experience. With takeout and catering options available, Country Crust Bakery is perfect for families and food lovers alike, though guests should come prepared for delightful al fresco dining.

Country Crust Bakery at a glance

  • Address 4918 State Rt 41 S Bainbridge, OH 45612 United States
  • Phone (740) 634-2253
  • Restaurant type Bakery , Coffee shop , Donut shop , Sandwich shop .

Photos & Gallery

Country Crust Bakery: Reviews & Ratings

Riz Rizobiz
5

Everything that this place produces is absolutely delicious. The pretzel bun sandwich is my favorite. The peanut butter cookies were absolutely the freshest and easily most addictive I've ever tried. The huge pretzels w cheese dipping sauce were a big hit back at the cabin. If you're in the area and really hungry, give them a try. Portions are very satisfying and the freshest you will find in the area.

James Welsh
5

Wonderfully delicious and large sandwiches freshly made. Scrumptious, mouthwatering baked goods. The place can be packed and there’s usually a line, especially on the weekends, but it moves fast. The trip out there is worth it and we always try to go when around. May 2021

Jeff Williamson
5

Really cool place. Be prepared to stand in line but they move quickly. Sandwiches are huge. Highly recommend toasted pretzel bun. Super fresh. Sweet treats are amazing. Apple fritter was so good.

Jeanie McVay
5

This is one of our all time favorite family places. My Uncle Len from Nevada loves this place and when he comes to visit we go here and he takes stuff home! The pretzel sandwiches are Amazing!!! They’re almost always busy but service is super fast and friendly and we love to sit outside and have family dates here. There’s also tons of hiking nearby so you can make a day of it. Enjoy.

Karen Warrick
5

A wonderful bakery with fantastic handmade pretzels. They also have added a hot pretzel sandwich or pizza window for a quick lunch stop. We had brisket on a pretzel bun sandwiches today. So good! We will definitely be back.

Ashley Taylor
5

My boyfriend and I stumbled on this place while driving to Chillicothe and we'll definitely be back! We both had the Reuben on a homemade pretzel bun, and it was out of this world. We also split a donut and it was the best either of us has ever had. Don't pass up this great restaurant and bakery!

Rachel Coffey
5

Literally the best donuts and pretzels I've ever had. The pizza is stellar too. This place never misses! No indoor bathroom (you have to use a port a potty) and they only take cash but hey it's Amish

Austin Yochus
5

Great little amish bakery with TONS of sweets to choose from and a few lunch/dinner items. Went for lunch and got a pretzel bun sandwich and a few other things. The sammy was massive and actually tasted delicious. Several combinations of meats, cheese, and toppings available. Build your own style. Same thing with pizza. People rave about the pretzels and I understand why. They also have donuts, cookies, pies, cakes, muffins, cinnamon rolls, bread, brownies, and more. All very reasonably priced in my opinion. Plenty of parking available as well as outdoor seating. This place gets busy on the weekends, waited in line maybe 10 min before ordering but the food came out pretty quickly. See photos for updated menu & pricing! CASH ONLY - NO CREDIT CARDS

Location

  • Country Crust Bakery
    Country Crust Bakery
    4918 State Rt 41 S Bainbridge, OH 45612 United States Hotline: (740) 634-2253

Welcome to Country Crust Bakery, a hidden gem nestled in the scenic landscapes of Bainbridge, Ohio. Located at 4918 State Rt 41 S, this charming eatery invites you to indulge in a delightful array of baked goods, made-to-order sandwiches, and comforting desserts—all with a touch of Amish heritage.

As you approach, you can’t help but notice the bustling outdoor patio, where eager diners savor the fresh air while enjoying their meals. Although the quaint establishment does not offer indoor seating, the ample outdoor seating is perfect for a leisurely lunch or an afternoon treat on pleasant days. Just remember to plan for inclement weather!

The menu at Country Crust Bakery is a culinary journey. One standout that patrons rave about is the soft pretzel bun, which elevates their sandwiches to new heights. Whether you opt for the corned beef or the zesty chicken salad, the pretzel bun adds a unique twist that enhances each bite. Diners like Farrah S. and Linda W. have praised the prompt and organized service, making for a pleasant dining experience.

  • Assorted Offerings: Dive into a variety of household favorites including pulled BBQ pork sandwiches and homemade pies. The pecan, peach, and apple pies receive high praise for their rich flavors.
  • Freshly Made Treats: From donuts and banana bread to jams and jellies, the bakery offers an array of mouthwatering baked goods that beckon you to indulge.
  • Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth: Customers frequently highlight the freshly made desserts. With treats around every corner, it's hard to resist a sugary delight after your meal.

It’s evident from the glowing reviews that Country Crust Bakery is more than just a place to grab a bite—it's a community staple. Diners often describe the cheerful atmosphere and exceptional service, creating an inviting environment where everyone feels welcome. As you visit, prepare to be greeted with smiles and a warm sense of hospitality, making your experience not just satisfying for the palate, but enjoyable overall.

One important note: remember to bring cash or a check, as the bakery does not accept credit or debit cards. With a robust menu and an undeniable charm, Country Crust Bakery is a must-visit for anyone looking to experience the authentic flavors of homemade goodness. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to delight in their signature selections!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Cash only